The Evening News photographs that changed
a week’s worth of Science lessons!
The nature of the Enhanced Learning Provision Science program lends itself to a significant degree of flexibility. The ability to stop and further explore concepts – sometimes over a couple of lessons -when a pupil makes an insightful contribution can be priceless. These times are sometimes referred to as “Eureka! Moments” by teachers.
This sort of change to the planned lesson outlines occured in spectacular fashion in the week of October 8th…when the Edinburgh Evening News of Saturday October 6th became the focus for a slight detour.
On the front page of the Evening News on the 6th October, the headline “Jaws drop as shark turns up on beach” was accompanied by a story of a basking shark being stranded in Musselburgh – just a few minutes up the coast from Prestonpans.
The Enhanced Learning Provision Science program were in the middle of a series of lessons and activities looking at the science of the River Forth – as part of our cross-curricular project on East Lothian. In fact, that very week the pupils had begun constructing their own model of an East Lothian beach – thinking about what sort of plant and wildlife might be present and where they might “live” in the river.
The story in the local newspaper was a fabulous opportunity to look more closely at this remarkable event on our own doorstep – and to consider it from a scientific perspective. It was indeed a Eureka Moment.
The story by H Mollinson in the Evening News had started with the following paragraph:
“It looked more like a scene from Jaws than an average day on peaceful Fisherrow Beach in East Lothian. People enjoying a quiet stroll could not believe their eyes when they saw a three-metre shark lurking in the shallows.
The basking shark, which had strayed from its normal habitat on the west coast of Scotland, was washed up injured on the beach yesterday. Despite a five-hour struggle by animal welfare workers to return it to the sea, the giant fish later died.
Marine experts think the shark may have followed shoals of plankton around the northern tip of Scotland and into unfamiliar east coast waters”.
The terms highlighted in bold green font were all terms we had been using the week before in class when thinking about how to plan our model of the beach. Here, only a couple of days later, was an exciting story in the newspaper that talked about many of the things we had discussed ourselves as a group.
We brought a hard copy of the paper into the classroom. It was to form the starting point for a very exciting and engaging conversation. We decided to allow the story to take us in an unplanned direction – and one that would allow us to bring in some literacy skills, numeracy skills and ICT skills.
As a group we part-read, part-listened to the full story of the Musselburgh shark. We then went on line to see if there were any other stories on the internet about our very own local Shark Tale. Of course, there were! We searched for some on line images that we might be able to use for any work we produced ourselves in the classroom.
We decided to make our own mind map showing all the things we had learned about the shark so far – we were surprised how much information we already had!
The ideas included:
-
the location of the stranded shark
-
the age of the shark
-
the length of the shark
-
the time and date of the shark incident
-
the pictures we found in the paper and online of the story
-
other witness accounts of the incident
-
the shark species name
-
the usual habitat of the basking shark
-
the usual diet of the basking shark
Once we had looked at all the information we already had, we thought it would be a good idea to do something with it. However, it was important the pupils had ownership of what that may be…
As a group we decided to make a presentation on the shark stranding to go alongside our model beach. This would involve the students:
-
creating a visual image of the shark as a centre piece (arts and/or ICT photography)
-
creating a clay model basking shark to be included in our model beach
-
presenting the data about the shark eg length, age etc (could extend this to also be incorporated into our maths lesson)
-
presenting the media clips/cuttings in a way that others could also access them
-
laminating the presentation for longevity (life skills)
The students thought they could report it “as if David Attenborough had been there” – they had this inspiration from having been fascinated by clips of the BBC’s Blue Planet used in an earlier lesson.
As far as Eureka Moments go, this was one of Great White proportions!